Call For 24/7 Emergency Service

Proudly Serving Greensburg, PA and surrounding areas

(724) 261-3634

Menu

Tank vs. Tankless Water Heater Systems

Traditional tank water heaters store between 30 and 80 gallons of heated water, maintaining temperature around the clock. These systems typically last 10-15 years with proper maintenance and work well for households with predictable hot water usage patterns. Gas-fired models heat water faster than electric units and generally cost less to operate, though installation requires proper venting and gas line connections. Electric tank heaters offer simpler installation but typically result in higher monthly operating costs.

Tankless water heaters, also called on-demand systems, heat water only when needed, eliminating standby energy losses that account for 15-20% of water heating costs in traditional systems. These compact units mount on walls, freeing valuable floor space, and provide endless hot water when properly sized. However, simultaneous high-demand uses like running multiple showers while operating a dishwasher may exceed a single unit’s capacity, sometimes requiring multiple heaters or careful usage planning. Our comfort consultants at Donahue's Heating & Cooling carefully calculate your household’s peak demand to ensure proper sizing.

Energy Efficiency and Operating Costs

Water heating typically accounts for 14-18% of residential energy consumption, making efficiency a crucial consideration. The Energy Factor (EF) rating measures overall efficiency, with higher numbers indicating better performance. Standard tank heaters range from 0.60-0.95 EF, while tankless units achieve 0.82-0.98 EF ratings. Heat pump water heaters lead efficiency metrics with ratings exceeding 2.0 EF, though their performance depends on ambient air temperature.

Annual operating costs vary significantly based on fuel type, local utility rates, and usage patterns. Natural gas tank heaters average $250-$350 annually, while electric models typically cost $400-$600. Tankless gas units reduce these costs by approximately 30%, though higher equipment and installation expenses mean payback periods often extend 7-12 years. As a customer-focused residential and commercial heating, air conditioning, and commercial refrigeration company, we help clients analyze total ownership costs, including purchase price, installation, energy consumption, and maintenance requirements.

Installation Considerations and Requirements

Proper installation ensures optimal performance, efficiency, and safety while meeting local building codes. Key factors we evaluate include:

  • Location and space requirements: Tank heaters need adequate clearance for maintenance access and proper ventilation
  • Fuel type availability: Natural gas, propane, or adequate electrical service capacity
  • Venting requirements: Gas units require proper exhaust venting to prevent carbon monoxide accumulation
  • Water supply connections: Proper sizing ensures adequate flow rates and pressure
  • Drainage provisions: Safety pans and drain lines prevent water damage from potential leaks

Our highly trained technicians handle everything from basic replacements to complex commercial installations. We specialize in both servicing and installing state of the art comfort systems, ensuring each installation meets manufacturer specifications and local codes. With 24/7 emergency service available, we respond quickly when unexpected failures occur, minimizing disruption to your daily routine or business operations.

Maintenance for Maximum Lifespan

Regular maintenance extends equipment life, maintains efficiency, and prevents unexpected failures. Tank-style heaters require annual flushing to remove sediment accumulation that reduces heating efficiency and tank capacity. Anode rod inspection and replacement every 3-5 years prevents tank corrosion, potentially doubling system lifespan. Temperature and pressure relief valve testing ensures this critical safety device functions properly.

Tankless systems need periodic descaling to remove mineral deposits that restrict water flow and reduce heat transfer efficiency. Hard water areas may require descaling every 6-12 months, while softer water regions might extend intervals to 2-3 years. Our service technicians use specialized pumps and safe descaling solutions to restore full performance without damaging sensitive components. Whether servicing room air conditioners or 200-ton industrial chillers, Donahue's Heating & Cooling ensures each piece of equipment receives appropriate care to maximize reliability and efficiency throughout its service life.

Your Comfort is Our Priority

Ready to Experience the Donahue’s Difference?

Don’t let another day go by with an uncomfortable home or unreliable HVAC system. For over 60 years, Donahue’s Heating & Cooling has been Greensburg’s trusted choice for expert HVAC solutions, emergency repairs, and comprehensive maintenance services. Our NATE-certified technicians are standing by 24/7 to restore your comfort and peace of mind.

Whether you need immediate emergency service, want to schedule routine maintenance, or are ready to upgrade to a more efficient system, we’re here to help. Call 724-261-3634 now or fill out our contact form to get started. As a Carrier authorized dealer with our own sheet metal fabrication shop, we have the expertise and resources to handle any HVAC challenge.

NATE-Certified Technicians Ready to Help
Quality service you can count on!
Three Generations of Excellence
See Why Greensburg Chooses Donahue’s

View More

Over 60 Years of Trusted Service
Customer Reviews
First time dealing with Donahue. We received a quote from Mark the same day he came to look at the job (amazing). After meeting with the other companies we contacted, we decided to go with Donahue’s. From estimates to office calls/visit, to the installation crew, we could not have been...
Scott M.
Google Review
Just had my a/c get its checkup for the upcoming season and Jeremy from Donahue’s did an excellent job! He went the extra mile to make sure everything was done completely and thoroughly! Just started using Donahue Heating and Cooling and this was my second excellent experience.
Daniel C.
Google Review
Great tech came to house to fix hvac Dillon was his name he explained everything it a way I could understand. He was very friendly and knowledgeable. If I need service again I will definitely be requesting him.
Brandon R.
Google Review
Donahue’s service man was timely, courteous, professional very knowledgeable and answered my questions. He completed a thorough maintenance check of our furnace. I definately recommend Donahue’s Heating & Cooling. I will call them again in the future.
Susan F.
Google Review
Donahue’s service is second to none! My tech, Dillon, was outstanding and very professional! Will definitely use them for future services. A+
Deb R.
Google Review
I’ve used Donahue’s for a few jobs now, some small and some big, one was a full furnace replacement and I couldn’t be happier with the work they did for me. All their employees have been great, the latest was Rod, he replaced the gas valve on my hot water...
Andrew K.
Google Review
We had Donahue’s clean our out vents and they did a fantastic job. Hunter, Tyler, Zack, and Kyle were all very respectful and were happy to answer any questions we had. I would strongly recommend using Donahue’s Heating & Cooling for your needs.
Anisa B.
Google Review
I have had Donahue’s provide Spring and Fall PM on both my heating and air conditioning units for a number of years. I am very impressed with both Dillon and Zach, who have performed the recent fall and spring PM visits. They were both very knowledgeable and courteous young men...
Ann P.
Google Review
I wanted in-ceiling mini splits and Dave Donahue came to my home to create an estimate and he was extremely professional and knowledgeable. The price was reasonable. The job was done promptly and finished earlier than the time frame promised His team was excellent. They were neat and tidy and...
Kelly E.
Google Review
Called to have service as my HVAC Unit wasn’t blowing cold this spring. They got me an appt for 2 days later, and called me a day earlier to let me know a tech was available. It worked for me so Zach came out and replaced a capacitor on my...
Matt G.
Google Review
We could not be happier with the central A/C job that was done in our over 100 year old home. We were so worried about losing valuable space that we held off exploring this. Now we are asking ourselves why we didn’t do it sooner! The whole experience was professional....
Amy M.
Google Review
One coldest days of year and my furnace shutdown. I used Donahue’s for years so I called asap . They had Zack at my house with in a hour and solved my problems. Happy day for me, furnace running perfect again . Excellent tech and office were both kind people...
David L.
Google Review
Donahue’s was amazing to deal with! Huge thank you to Todd the technician who fixed our air conditioner! Very knowledgeable and informative. I would highly recommend Donahue’s!!
Alicia P.
Google Review
Dillon was our service tech, and did a great job on both service calls! He first did our furnace maintenance, where he was personable and efficient. He explained that we needed to replace our combustion tank, and quoted us on the spot. His second trip was to replace the tank...
Wendy V.
Google Review
My in-laws were having low air flow with their central air conditioning system and called Donahues to address it. They were immediately put on a wait list, but were seen the next day! Dan came out and did a thorough inspection inside, changed the filter, and then thoroughly checked the...
Victoria B.
Google Review
We switched to electric heat in 2022 from oil. A new variable speed air handler was installed by a different vendor, using the 3 zone control system that this vendor had installed in 2004. However, the original zoning controller was not capable of optimally using the capability of the new...
Daniel A.
Google Review

Water Heater Service

Water Heater Maintenance

Jeanette, PA

Youngwood, PA

Harrison, PA

New Stanton, PA

Lawson Heights, PA

Delmont, PA